371
Journal of Muscle Research and Cell Motility 22: 371±378, 2001. Ó 2001 Kluwer Academic Publishers. Printed in the Netherlands.
Phalloidin aects the myosin-dependent sliding velocities of actin ®laments in a bound-divalent cation dependent manner KIYOTAKA TOKURAKU1,2,* and TARO Q. P. UYEDA2 1 Department of Chemical Science and Engineering, Miyakonojo National College of Technology, 473-1 Yoshio-cho, Miyakonojo, Miyazaki 885-8567; 2Gene Discovery Research Center, National Institute of Advanced Industrial Science and Technology, 1-1-1 Higashi, Tsukuba, Ibaraki 305-8562, Japan Received 3 July 2001; accepted in revised form 15 August 2001
Abstract We examined sliding velocities in vitro of four types of actin ®laments, that is, ®laments with Ca2 or Mg2 bound at the high anity metal binding site, each with rhodamine phalloidin bound with a high or low stoichiometry. When surfaces coated with a high density of heavy meromyosin (HMM) were used, high stoichiometric concentrations of rhodamine phalloidin reduced sliding velocities of only Ca2-actin ®laments, by 40%. As the HMM density on surfaces was reduced, continuous movement of actin ®laments became dependent on the presence of methylcellulose and sliding velocities of all four types became progressively slower. Interestingly, Ca2-actin ®laments with a high stoichiometric concentration of rhodamine phalloidin were the fastest among the four types of ®laments on sparse HMM surfaces. In contrast, phalloidin did not aect steady state ATPase activities of HMM in the presence of Ca2- or Mg2-actin ®laments. We speculate that the reversal of the order of sliding velocities among the four types of actin ®laments between high and low densities of HMM relates with dierent axial elasticity of the actin ®laments, so that stier ®laments move slower on dense HMM surfaces, but faster on sparse surfaces, than elastic ones.
Introduction Phalloidin, a cellular toxin of fungal origin, binds to actin with a high anity (Kd is 10)8 M) at a 1:1 stoichiometric concentration (Wieland et al., 1975). Upon the binding, actin polymerization is promoted (Dancker et al., 1975) and the actin ®laments are stabilized against depolymerization (Low et al., 1975; Estes et al., 1981). Fluorescently-labeled phalloidin has been widely used in in vitro motility assays, in order to stabilize and visualize actin ®laments sliding on myosincoated surfaces. Binding of phalloidin aects various other properties of actin ®laments as well. For example, phalloidin binding reduces bending and torsional ¯exibility of actin ®laments (Isambert et al., 1995; Rebello and Ludescher, 1998). It is known that binding of myosin to actin ®laments is coopearative, so that bound myosin molecules tend to form clusters along actin ®laments when myosin is present at very low stoichiometric concentration against actin subunits (Woodrum et al., 1975). There is evidence that bound phalloidin interferes with this cooperative binding between myosin and actin ®laments (Orlova and Egelman, 1997). It was reported that phalloidin has an activating eect on striated muscle (Bukatina and Fuchs, 1994; Bukatina et al., *To whom correspondence should be addressed: Tel.: 81-986-47-1221; Fax: 81-986-47-1231; E-mail:
[email protected]
1995), but a recent analysis failed to detect eects of phalloidin on in vitro actomyosin sliding and ATPase activities (VanBuren et al., 1998). Thus, consequences of phalloidin bound to actin on the actomyosin interactions remain elusive. Divalent cations also bind actin. Either Ca2 or Mg2 bind to the single divalent cation binding site of actin with a high-anity (Kd 10)8 M for both Ca2 and Mg2) (Estes et al., 1992), and the type of bound cation aects various properties of actin as well. For instance, the polymerization kinetics of Ca2-actin were dierent from those of Mg2-actin (Carlier et al., 1986) and the tertiary structures of actin ®laments can be altered depending on the type of tightly bound divalent cation (Orlova and Egelman, 1992, 1993, 1995; Orlova et al., 1995). Moreover, torsional ¯exibility of Ca2-actin ®laments is dierent from those of Mg2-actin ®laments (Yasuda et al., 1996; Rebello and Ludescher, 1998). Eects of myosin-binding on dynamic rotational motion of actin ®laments is also dierent between Ca2- and Mg2-actin ®laments (Rebello and Ludescher, 1999). With respect to the cooperative binding between actin and myosin, bound Mg2 abolishes this cooperativity (Orlova and Egelman, 1997). Consequently, there is a considerable degree of overlap among the published eects of actin-bound Ca2/Mg2 and phalloidin on structural and biochemical parameters such as ®lament ¯exibility and cooperative binding with myosin. Yet, the physiological or
372 functional signi®cances of binding Ca2/Mg2 and phalloidin to actin ®laments has not been elucidated. We were interested to know if the actomyosin sliding mechanism is aected by bound Ca2/Mg2 and phalloidin, and if it is, whether it is correlated with the cooperativity of actin±myosin binding, or the stiness of actin ®laments. Therefore, we have examined the sliding velocities in vitro of actin ®laments carrying either Ca2 or Mg2, and with a high or low stoichiometric concentrations of bound rhodamine phalloidin. We found that Ca2/Mg2, and rhodamine phalloidin aect actomyosin sliding velocity in a manner well correlated with the elasticity of actin ®laments.
Acto-HMM ATPase assays were carried out in reaction solutions which contained 0.1 lM HMM, various concentrations of Ca2- or Mg2-actin ®laments, with or without phalloidin, and 2 mM ATP in the Mg2-buer at 30°C. The liberated Pi was quanti®ed by a modi®ed malachite green method (Kodama et al., 1986). Ca2- or Mg2-actin ®laments were added to the mixture immediately before the reaction was started by the addition of ATP.
Materials and methods
Eects of rhodamine phalloidin on sliding velocities
Protein preparation
We ®rst examined whether binding of rhodamine phalloidin aects sliding velocity of Ca2- or Mg2actin ®laments. The labeled actin ®laments were diluted in the Mg2-buer, and immediately introduced into ¯ow chambers that consisted of a glass slide, pairs of spacers, and a nitrocellulose-coated coverslip on which a high density of HMM had been absorbed. After incubating for 1 min at 30°C, the Mg2-buer containing 2 mM ATP was introduced to initiate the movement. When the concentration of rhodamine phalloidin was low, yielding the stoichiometric ratio of rhodamine phalloidin to actin subunits of 1:20 (RP0.05), sliding velocities of both Ca2- and Mg2-actin ®lament were approximately 9 lm/s (Figure 1A). Sliding velocity of Mg2-actin ®laments slightly decreased with the increase of concentration of rhodamine phalloidin (Figure 1A, circles). In contrast, a stoichiometric concentration of rhodamine phalloidin (RP1)a decreased velocity of Ca2-actin ®laments by more than 30% to 6 lm/s (Figure 1A, squares). Increasing the concentration of rhodamine phalloidin to twofold molar excess over the actin subunits further decreased sliding velocities of Ca2-actin ®laments to 5 lm/s, which is a 40% decrease compared with RP0.05. Additional increase of the concentration of rhodamine phalloidin was not feasible due to very high background ¯uorescence during observation. Therefore, to investigate possible eects of large excess of phalloidin on sliding velocities, 200-fold molar excess of unlabeled phalloidin was added to actin ®laments that had been labeled with a stoichiometric concentration of rhodamine phalloidin (shown at RP/actin of 200 in Figure 1A). These actin ®laments moved at speeds similar to those labeled with twofold molar excess of rhodamine phalloidin, indicating that twofold molar excess is saturating in terms of slowing the sliding velocities of Ca2-actin ®laments. The concentration of actin subunits is extremely low after dilution in preparation for the
Actin and myosin were prepared from rabbit skeletal muscle by the standard methods (Pardee and Spudich, 1982; Hynes et al., 1987). G-actin was further puri®ed by gel ®ltration chromatography using Superose 6 (Amersham Pharmacia Biotech, Buckinghamshire, UK) in 5 mM Tris±Cl, 0.2 mM DTT, 0.1 mM CaCl2, 1.5 mM NaN3, 0.2 mM ATP, pH 7.8. Rabbit skeletal muscle heavy meromyosin (HMM) and myosin subfragment 1 (S1) were prepared by the method of Okamoto and Sekine (1985). Protein concentrations were determined by the method of Lowry et al. (1951) using bovine albumin as the standard. Ca2- or Mg2actin monomer was prepared according to Yasuda et al. (1996). To polymerize Ca2- or Mg2-actin ®laments, G-actin (Ca2- or Mg2-) was dialyzed against Ca2buer (4 mM CaCl2, 25 mM Imidazole, 25 mM KCl, and 1 mM DTT, pH 7.4) or Mg2-buer (4 mM MgCl2, 25 mM Imidazole, 25 mM KCl, and 1 mM DTT, pH 7.4) containing 0.1 mM ATP for 3 h. Ca2- or Mg2actin ®laments were labeled with rhodamine phalloidin at various stoichiometries by incubating them in either Ca2- or Mg2-buer containing various concentrations of rhodamine phalloidin (Molecular Probes, Eugene, USA) overnight on ice. The concentration of actin during the labeling reaction was 100 lg/ml. Immediately before use these solutions of labeled actin ®laments were diluted 100-fold in the Mg2-buer. In vitro motility assay In vitro motility assays were carried out according to Kron et al. (1991) using the Mg2-buer containing 2 mM ATP at 30°C. For assays on surfaces only sparsely coated with HMM, 0.8% methylcellulose was added to the assay buer to suppress lateral diusion of actin ®laments away from the surfaces (Uyeda et al., 1990). Sliding velocities of actin ®laments were determined manually by tracking the leading edges of the actin ®laments at intervals of 0.5 s during the period of 1.5 s.
Acto-HMM ATPase assay
Results
a
Rhodamine phalloidin was present at a stoichiometric concentration of 1:1 with respect to actin subunits during the labeling reaction.
373
Fig. 1. Eect of rhodamine phalloidin on sliding velocity in vitro. A, Ca2-actin ®laments (h) and Mg2-actin ®laments (s) were labeled with various stoichiometries of rhodamine phalloidin and their sliding velocities on HMM surfaces were measured (concentration of HMM in the absorption buer was 0.8 lM). The motility assays were carried out in the Mg2-Buer. Vertical axis and horizontal axes are sliding velocities of each type of ®laments (n 25) and the stoichiometric concentration of rhodamine phalloidin to actin, respectively. The exceptions are data points at RP/actin of 200, as explained in the text. Error bars denote standard deviations. Sliding velocities of Ca2-actin ®laments (n) and Mg2-actin ®laments (d) were also measured on S1 surfaces (concentration of S1 in the absorption buer was 1 lM). Error bars of the data points for S1 are hidden behind the symbols. B, Ca2-actin ®laments (h) and Mg2-actin ®laments (s) were labeled with various stoichiometries of rhodamine phalloidin and the images were observed under a ¯uorescence microscope. Fluorescence intensity along a unit axial length of each actin ®lament (n 20) was measured by analyzing digitized images using the NIH image software.
motility assay, and we speculate that higher stoichiometric concentrations of rhodamine phalloidin or unlabeled phalloidin prevents their dissociation from actin ®laments after this dilution step. To eliminate the possibility that the weak inhibitory eect of rhodamine phalloidin on sliding movement of Mg2-actin ®laments was caused by its lower anity for Mg2-actin ®laments, we compared relative anities of rhodamine phalloidin between these two types of actin. The anities were estimated by measuring ¯uorescence intensities of rhodamine phalloidin-labeled ®laments observed under a ¯uorescence microscope (Figure 1B).
Fluorescence intensity of the actin ®laments increased with the increase of stoichiometric concentrations of rhodamine phalloidin, and saturated when stoichiometric concentration was more than 1.5. The ¯uorescence intensity curves of Ca2- and Mg2-actin ®laments were practically indistinguishable from each other, indicating that the anities of phalloidin for Ca2- and Mg2actin ®laments are the same. Taken together, we conclude that rhodamine phalloidin bound to Ca2actin ®laments exerts a large inhibitory eect on the movement while that bound to Mg2-actin ®laments has negligible eects. There was a concern that Ca2 bound to actin may be replaced by Mg2 in the Mg2-buer during the assay, and the velocities of ®laments that we thought were Ca2-actin ®laments were in fact those of Mg2-actin ®laments. This does not appear to be the case, as earlier biochemical studies have shown that the exchange of divalent cations bound to the high anity metal binding sites of actin ®laments is an extremely slow process (Kasai and Oosawa, 1969; Estes et al., 1992). Furthermore, Ca2-actin ®laments with a high stoichiometric concentrations of rhodamine phalloidin consistently moved at a slower speed than Mg2-actin ®laments with the same stoichiometric concentration of rhodamine phalloidin, and this speed dierence did not change within a time span of up to 10 min (data not shown), indicating that the exchange of bound Ca2 with Mg2 did not occur at appreciable levels under our experimental conditions. We also carried out in vitro motility assays using S1 instead of HMM. The sliding velocities of Ca2-actin (RP1) and Mg2-actin (RP1) were 1.1 and 1.8 lm/s, respectively. These sliding velocities were much lower than that over HMM-coated surfaces, as has been reported previously by Toyoshima et al. (1987). Notably, the ratio of velocities between the two types of actin ®laments on S1-coated surfaces (approximately 1.6) was similar to that over HMM-coated surfaces (1.5), suggesting that a common mechanism, not directly related to the motor function, is aecting the sliding velocities in both cases. Eects of HMM densities on sliding velocities We next examined eects of changing HMM densities on assay surfaces (Figure 2). Our initial attempt to prepare surfaces of uniform, low densities of motors by simply introducing diluted HMM solutions into ¯ow chambers was not very successful, with the tendency to result in higher densities of motors near the intake of the ¯ow chamber than other parts of the surface (result not shown). We have therefore modi®ed the procedure to absorb HMM on nitrocellulose surfaces. First, two pieces of double-sided adhesive tape were placed on a glass slide, and a drop of the Mg2-buer containing diluted HMM was placed between these spacers. A coverslip with nitrocellulose coating was quickly placed
374 (RP1) or low (RP0.05) stoichiometric concentration of rhodamine phalloidin, were measured and plotted against the concentrations of HMM in the initial absorption solution (Figure 2A). At the same time, the number of sliding actin ®laments in 1 mm2 were counted, and were plotted against the concentration of HMM (Figure 2B). When HMM concentration was less than 0.18 lM, all actin ®laments were released from the surface upon addition of ATP (Figure 2B). The release of actin ®laments caused their diusion away from the surface by Brownian movements (Uyeda et al., 1990). Above HMM concentrations of 0.18 lM, Ca2-actin ®laments (RP1) showed the lowest sliding velocity as compared with the other three types of actin ®laments (Figure 2A). HMM concentration did not have significant eects on sliding velocities of each type actin ®laments, as long as the density of HMM molecules are above a certain threshold value. Eects of low HMM densities on sliding velocities in the presence of methylcellulose
Fig. 2. Eect of HMM density on sliding velocity. Sliding velocities of Ca2-actin ®laments (RP1) (j), Ca2-actin ®laments (RP0.05) (h), Mg2-actin ®laments (RP1) (d), and Mg2-actin ®laments (RP0.05) (s) were measured on surfaces with various densities of HMM in the absence of methylcellulose. The velocities were measured between 1 and 3 min after the addition of ATP. A, Sliding velocities of actin ®laments (n 25) were plotted against the concentrations of HMM in the absorption buer. All ®laments were released from the surfaces when HMM concentration was less than 0.18 lM (- - -). B, Number of actin ®laments per 1 mm2 at 1 to 3 min after the addition of ATP was plotted against the concentrations of HMM in the absorption buer. Error bars denote standard deviations.
over the HMM solution and the spacers, and a ¯ow chamber was constructed. After incubation for 1 min at 30°C, a blocking solution which consisted of the Mg2buer and 1 mg/ml bovine serum albumin was introduced from one of the two openings. Surfaces prepared in this way had relatively uniform densities of motors, as judged by the uniformity of sliding velocities at dierent parts of the same ¯ow chamber (not shown). Hereafter, we use the concentration of HMM in the solution used in the initial absorption, rather than the actual density of HMM molecules on the surface, to refer to the surface density of HMM. Sliding velocities of four types of actin ®laments, Ca2- or Mg2-actin ®laments, each labeled with a high
To measure sliding velocities over surfaces with low HMM densities, which cannot support continuous sliding movement under standard in vitro motility assay conditions, we carried out assays in the presence of 0.8% methylcellulose (Figure 3). When HMM concentration was higher than 0.3 lM (data not shown), sliding velocities were similar to those without methylcellulose (Figure 2). Sliding velocities of Ca2-actin ®laments (RP0.05) (Figure 3A) and Mg2actin ®laments (both RP1 and RP0.05) (Figure 3B) remained relatively constant, independent of the HMM concentration, when it was higher than approximately 0.08 lM. On the other hand, sliding velocity of Ca2actin ®laments (RP1) increased with the decrease of HMM concentration when HMM concentration was between 0.3 and 0.06 lM, and the maximum velocity was achieved at 0.06 lM of HMM concentration (Figure 3A). This maximum velocity at the HMM concentration of 0.06 lM was similar to velocities of other types of actin ®laments at the same HMM density. When HMM concentration was reduced below 0.06 lM, sliding velocity of Ca2-actin ®laments (RP1) declined, but at a rate smaller than that of the other types of ®laments. Notably, this resulted in the reversal of the order of velocities among the four types of actin ®laments, and Ca2-actin ®laments (RP1) were the fastest at very low HMM densities. When HMM concentration was 0.02 lM, sliding velocities of Ca2actin ®laments (RP1) and Ca2-actin ®laments (RP0.05) were 2.9 and 2.1 lm/s, respectively (Figure 3B). The dierence between these two velocities is small, but is statistically signi®cant (P < 0:01). This reversal in the order of velocities was also observed when rhodamine phalloidin was present at a twofold molar excess over actin subunits (data not shown).
375 Table 1. Kapp and Vmax of actomyosin ATPase Kapp (lM)
Vmax (s)1)
Ca2-actin (P1) Ca2-actin (P0.05)
22.8 6.2 19.4 3.7
16.8 6.0 14.4 3.5
Mg2-actin (P1) Mg2-actin (P0.05)
16.1 1.1 17.5 1.6
10.0 0.8 10.0 1.1
with a high (P1)b or low (P0.05)c stoichiometric concentration of phalloidin. To exclude possible eects of dierent cations on HMM, all assays were carried out in a common buer (Mg2-buer). Concentrated Ca2actin ®laments maintained in the Ca2-buer were added to the assay mixture immediately before the onset of the reaction, and the reactions were terminated within 10 min. In vitro motility assays had demonstrated that the exchange of actin-bound Ca2 with Mg2 is negligible in 10 min. Kapp for actin and Vmax of acto-HMM ATPase using Ca2-actin ®laments were dierent from those using Mg2-actin ®laments. However, phalloidin had no eect on ATPase activities using either Ca2- or Mg2-actin ®laments. These results indicated that actin-bound cation aects ATPase activities but phalloidin has no relevance to the steady state ATPase activities in solution. Discussion
Fig. 3. Sliding velocities on surfaces with low HMM densities. To measure sliding velocities on low HMM density surfaces, assays were carried out in the presence of 0.8% methylcellulose. A, Sliding velocities of Ca2-actin ®laments (RP1) (j) and Ca2-actin ®laments (RP0.05) (h) were plotted against HMM concentrations in the absorption buer. B, Magni®ed plot of the low HMM concentration region from A (Ca2-actin ®laments). C, Sliding velocities of Mg2-actin ®laments (RP1) (d) and Mg2-actin ®laments (RP0.05) (s) were plotted against concentrations of HMM in the absorption buer. Error bars denote standard deviations (n 25).
Eects of phalloidin on acto-HMM ATPase activities Finally we examined whether phalloidin aects actoHMM ATPase activities (Table 1). Acto-HMM ATPase activities were measured by a modi®ed malachite green method (Kodama et al., 1986) using four types of actin ®laments, Ca2- or Mg2-actin ®laments each labeled b
Phalloidin was present at a stoichiometric concentration of 1:1 with respect to actin subunits during the labeling reaction.
In this paper, we have characterized four types of actin ®laments, that is, actin ®laments with Ca2 or Mg2 bound at the high anity divalent cation binding site, each labeled with a high (1:1) or low (1:0.05) stoichiometric concentration of phalloidin or rhodamine phalloidin, in in vitro motility and steady state ATPase assays. The results demonstrated that rhodamine phalloidin aects actomyosin sliding velocity without impacting the ATPase activity. The eect of rhodamine phalloidin on sliding of Ca2-actin ®laments was larger than that on Mg2-actin ®laments. In the presence of a high density of HMM on surfaces (Table 2, concentration of HMM in the absorption buer = 0.5 lM), velocity of Ca2-actin ®laments (RP1) was reduced by one third when compared with those bound with a smaller stoichiometric concentration of rhodamine phalloidin, and was the slowest among the four types of ®laments. However, when HMM density was low (Table 2, concentration of HMM in the absorption buer = 0.02 lM), Ca2-actin ®laments (RP1) were the fastest among the four types of ®laments. Rhodamine phalloidin used in this study contains four stereo-isomers. However, the dierences are outside the actin binding region of the molecules, and the anities of these isomers to actin ®laments are more or less c
Phalloidin was present at a stoichiometric concentration of 1:20 with respect to actin subunits during the labeling reaction.
376 Table 2. Sliding velocity and torsional ¯exibility of actin ®lament Velocity (lm/s) HMM 0.5 lMc
HMM 0.02 lMd
a rFA
Torsional rigidityb (Nm2)
Ca2-actin (RP1) Ca2-actin (RP0.05)
5.0 0.5 8.3 0.5
4.6 0.8 3.0 0.5
0.098 0.005 0.083 0.002
8.5 1.3 ´ 10)26 ±
Mg2-actin (RP1) Mg2-actin (RP0.05)
8.8 0.6 9.0 0.9
2.9 0.6 2.1 0.3
0.080 0.005 0.066 0.002
2.8 0.3 ´ 10)26 ±
a
Phosphorescence emission anisotropies that were reported by Rebello and Ludescher (1998). Torsional rigidities that were reported Yasuda et al. (1996). c Means of velocities standard deviations of 25 ®laments from Figure 2. d Means of velocities standard deviations of 25 ®laments from Figure 3. b
similar to each other (Faulstich et al., 1988). Therefore, we do not think that the existence of the isomers should have much to do with the dierential eects rhodamine phalloidin exerted on Ca2- and Mg2-actin ®laments. How then is this complex behavior of Ca2-actin ®laments (RP1) in the motility assays related to its structural or biochemical property? Video microscopic and electron microscopic observations of actin ®laments failed to detect dierences in ¯exural ¯exibility of Ca2and Mg2-actin ®laments (Isambert et al., 1995; Yasuda et al., 1996; Steinmetz et al., 1997). However, Yasuda et al. (1996) estimated the torsional rigidity of actin ®laments on the millisecond to second time scales by observing motion of beads attached to the ®laments, and found that phalloidin-stabilized Ca2-actin ®laments are three times torsionally more rigid than phalloidin-stabilized Mg2-actin ®laments (Table 2). More recently, Rebello and Ludescher (1998) estimated torsional ¯exibility of actin ®laments on the micro- to milli-second time scale by measuring phosphorescence emission anisotropy (Table 2). They reported that Mg2-actin ®laments (rFA = 0.066) were more ¯exible than Ca2-actin ®laments (rFA = 0.083). They also reported that phalloidin lowered the ¯exibility of both Mg2-actin ®laments (rFA = 0.080) and Ca2-actin ®laments (rFA = 0.098) (Table 2). Considering the double-helical nature of actin ®laments, the dierence in torsional rigidity between Ca2- and Mg2-actin ®laments suggests a dierence in the extensile elasticity of ®laments along the axial direction. In other words, it is probable that Ca2-actin ®laments, particularly Ca2-actin ®laments (RP1), may be less elastic than Mg2-actin ®laments. Elasticity of phalloidin-stabilized Mg2-actin ®laments has been directly measured by nanomanipulation techniques (Kojima et al., 1994), but an experimental comparison of elasticity between Ca2and Mg2-actin ®laments and examination of the possible eects of bound phalloidin have not been reported so far. Based on the assumption that bound Ca2 or Mg2 and phalloidin aects elasticity of actin ®laments, we propose a hypothesis which qualitatively explains the complex eects phalloidin binding exerts on sliding velocities. When HMM density is high, one ®lament simultaneously interacts strongly with multiple myosin
heads. Those myosin heads which have ®nished the power stroke but are still strongly attached to the ®lament would experience negative strain and impose a load on the movement of ®laments, which is powered by other strongly bound heads performing power strokes or in the positive strain (Huxley, 1957). Such mechanical interference between heads that are producing positive and negative strains is mediated by the stiness of actin ®laments, and stier ®laments should be more prone to this interference, and hence to the load imposed by negatively-strained heads. This may be the reason why the velocity of Ca2-actin ®laments (RP1) is the slowest among the four types of actin ®laments moving over high density HMM surfaces. This scenario also explains why its sliding velocities increase when the HMM concentration in the absorption buer was decreased from 0.25 to 0.06 lM and the average distance between heads that are strongly bound along actin ®laments increases (Figure 3A). When the HMM density is very low, each actin ®lament would interact strongly with only one or a small number of myosin heads at a moment. Under such conditions, interference between strongly bound heads becomes infrequent and less of a problem. Instead, displacement generated at one point along the length of an actin ®lament is more eciently transmitted to other parts of the ®lament, if the ®lament is stier. A larger fraction of the local displacement of a ®lament should be dissipated in compression or stretching of the ®lament for more elastic ®laments. Thus it is expected that the stiest, Ca2-actin ®laments (RP1) move fastest on sparse HMM surfaces (Figure 3B). Orlova and Egelman (1997) reported that the cooperativity of binding between myosin and actin ®laments is larger with Ca2-actin ®laments than with Mg2-actin ®laments. This ®nding is particularly intriguing because cooperative binding has a potential to promote actomyosin interactions and aect the sliding velocity. However, dierence in the cooperativity of binding does not seem to be the cause of the observed dierent sliding velocities between Ca2- and Mg2-actin ®laments (RP1), since the eect of phalloidin binding on the cooperativity and that on the sliding velocity do not correlate with each other. Cooperative binding between HMM and Ca2-actin ®laments was abolished by a high
377 stoichiometric concentration of bound phalloidin, so that phalloidin-bound Ca2-actin ®laments were similar to phalloidin-bound Mg2-actin ®laments in terms of the poor cooperativity (Orlova and Egelman, 1997). In contrast, the dierence in sliding velocities between Ca2- and Mg2-actin ®laments was larger in the presence of a high stoichiometric concentration of rhodamine phalloidin. Alternatively, the complex eect of phalloidin binding on sliding velocity may be an indirect consequence of its impact on the kinetics of myosin ATPase. However, we do not think this scenario very likely for the following three reasons. First, the kinetic alteration model is unable to explain why phalloidin aects sliding velocity of Ca2-actin ®laments in opposite directions depending on the density of HMM on surfaces. Second, the kinetic alteration model is not consistent with the fact that the ratio between the sliding velocities of the Ca2- and Mg2-actin ®laments (RP1) over S1-coated surfaces and that over HMM-coated surfaces were very similar to each other, even though the absolute values of the sliding velocities, and hence kinetic parameters which determine the sliding velocities, were dierent by a factor of ®ve. Third, we were unable to ®nd evidence to suggest that the kinetics is altered by phalloidin. Each myosin head alternates between strongly-bound and weakly-bound states with actin in each ATPase cycle. The length of the strongly bound state is relatively short, but the length of this state, rather than the length of the total cycle time, primarily determines the sliding velocity (Harada et al., 1990; Uyeda et al., 1990). The ratio of the length of the strongly bound state to that of the total cycle time is called the duty ratio. Thus, even though phalloidin does not aect the steady state ATPase activity in the presence of Ca2-actin ®laments, it could alter the length of the strongly bound state and the duty ratio simultaneously, and hence, the sliding velocity. Therefore, we have performed an indirect assessment of whether phalloidin binding aects the duty ratio. In conventional sliding ®lament-type in vitro motility assays without viscous additives such as methylcellulose, continuous sliding movement of ®laments requires that each ®lament is always held by at least one motor molecule in the strongly bound state. The number of motor molecules strongly interacting with a unit length of a ®lament is proportional to the surface density of motors and to the duty ratio. Consequently, there is a threshold density of motors on surfaces that is required to support continuous movement of ®laments, and the threshold density is a function of the duty ratio (Toyoshima et al., 1990). We have demonstrated that all four types of actin ®laments became unable to move continuously and diuse away from surfaces at the same HMM density (Figure 2B). This result indicates that the duty ratio, and hence the length of the strongly bound state, is unaected by phalloidin binding. VanBuren et al. (1998) reported that ¯uorescent phalloidin has no eect on sliding velocity of actin
®laments on HMM surfaces. They carried out in vitro motility assays using Mg2-actin ®laments in a Mg2containing buer. We have con®rmed these results that rhodamine phalloidin has only a minor eect on sliding velocity of Mg2-actin ®laments. However, our data demonstrated that sliding velocity of Ca2-actin ®laments is signi®cantly aected and lowered by more than 40% by rhodamine phalloidin. These results indicate that sliding velocities in vitro are aected by multiple factors in a complex manner, and that, for quantitative analyses, attention should be paid regarding what divalent cation is bound to actin, and to what extent actin ®lament is labeled with phalloidin.
Acknowledgements We thank Mr Leonardo Mendoza for reading the manuscript. This work is supported by Japan Science and Technology Corporation and a Grants-in-Aid to T. U. from the Ministry of Education, Science, Culture of Japan.
References Bukatina AE and Fuchs F (1994) Eect of phalloidin on the ATPase activity of striated muscle myo®brils. J Muscle Res Cell Motil 13: 29±36. Bukatina AE, Fuchs F and Brandt PW (1995) Thin ®lament activation by phalloidin in skinned cardiac muscle. J Mol Cell Cardiol 27: 1311±1315. Carlier MF, Pantaloni D and Korn ED (1986) The eects of Mg2 at the high-anity and low-anity sites on the polymerization of actin and associated ATP hydrolysis. J Biol Chem 261: 10785± 10792. Dancker P, Low I, Hasselbach W and Wieland T (1975) Interaction of actin with phalloidin: polymerization and stabilization of F-actin. Biochemica Biophysica Acta 400: 407±414. Estes JE, Selden LA and Gershman LC (1981) Mechanism of action of phalloidin on the polymerization of muscle actin. Biochemistry 20: 708±712. Estes JE, Selden LA, Kinosian HJ and Gersham LC (1992) Tightlybound divalent cation of actin. J Muscle Res Cell Motil 13: 272± 284. Faulstich H, Zobeley S, Rinnerthaler G and Small JV (1988) Fluorescent phallotoxins as probes for ®lamentous actin. J Muscle Res Cell Motil 9: 370±383. Harada Y, Sakurada K, Aoki T, Thomas DD and Yanagida T (1990) Mechanochemical coupling in actomyosin energy transduction studied by in vitro movement assay. J Mol Biol 216: 49±68. Huxley AF (1957) Muscle structure and theories of contraction. Prog Biophys Biophys Chem 7: 255±318. Isambert H, Venier P, Maggs AC, Fattoum A, Kassab R, Pantaloni D and Carlier MF (1995) Flexibility of actin ®laments derived from thermal ¯uctuation. J Biol Chem 270: 11437±11444. Kasai M and Oosawa F (1969) Behavior of divalent cations and nucleotides bound to F-actin. Biochim Biophys Acta 172: 300± 310. Kodama T, Fukui K and Kometani K (1986) The initial phosphate burst in ATP hydrolysis by myosin and subfragment-1 as studied by a modi®ed malachite green method for determination of inorganic phosphate. J Biochem 99: 1465±1472.
378 Kojima H, Ishijima A and Yanagida T (1994) Direct measurement of stiness of single actin ®laments with and without tropomyosin by in vitro nanomanipulation. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 91: 12962±12966. Kron SJ, Toyoshima YY, Uyeda TQP and Spudich JA (1991) Assay for actin sliding movement over myosin-coated surfaces. In: Vallee RB (ed.) Methods Enzymology. (vol. 196, pp. 399±416) Academic Press, New York. Low I, Dancker P and Wieland T (1975) Stabilization of F-actin by phalloidin reversal of the destabilizing eect of cytochalasin B. FEBS 54: 263±265. Lowry OH, Rosebrough NJ, Farr AL and Randall RJ (1951) Protein measurement with the folin phenol reagent. J Biol Chem 193: 265± 275. Okamoto Y and Sekine T (1985) A streamlined method of subfragment one preparation from myosin. J Biochem 98: 1143±1145. Orlova A and Egelman EH (1992) Structural basis for the destabilization of F-actin by phosphate release following ATP hydrolysis. J Mol Biol 227: 1043±1053. Orlova A and Egelman EH (1993) A conformational change in the actin subunit can change the ¯exibility of the actin ®lament. J Mol Biol 232: 334±341. Orlova A and Egelman EH (1995) Structural dynamics of F-actin: I. Changes in the C terminus. J Mol Biol 245: 582±597. Orlova A and Egelman EH (1997) Cooperative rigor binding of myosin to actin is a function of F-actin structure. J Mol Biol 265: 469±474. Orlova A, Prochniewicz E and Egelman EH (1995) Structural dynamics of F-actin: II. Cooperativity in structural transitions. J Mol Biol 245: 598±607. Pardee JD and Spudich JA (1982) Puri®cation of muscle actin. In: Frederiksen DW and Cunningham LW (eds). Methods Enzymology. (vol. 85, pp. 164±181) Academic Press, New York.
Rebello CA and Ludescher RD (1998) In¯uence of tightly bound Mg2 and Ca2, nucleotides, and phalloidin on the microsecond torsional ¯exibility of F-actin. Biochemistry 37: 14529±14538. Rebello CA and Ludescher RD (1999) Dierential dynamic behavior of actin ®lament containing tightly-bound Ca2 or Mg2 in the presence of myosin heads activity hydrolyzing ATP. Biochemistry 38: 13288±13295. Steinmetz MO, Goldie KN and Aebi U (1997) A correlative analysis of actin ®lament assembly, structure, and dynamics. J Cell Biol 138: 559±574. Toyoshima YY, Kron SJ, McNally EM, Niebling KR, Toyoshima C and Spudich JA (1987) Myosin subfragment-1 is sucient to move actin ®laments in vitro. Nature 328: 536±539. Toyoshima YY, Kron SJ and Spudich JA (1990) The myosin step size: measurement of the unit displacement per ATP hydrolyzed in an in vitro assay. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 87: 7130±7134. Uyeda TQP, Kron SJ and Spudich JA (1990) Myosin step size: estimation from slow sliding movement of actin over low densities of heavy meromyosin. J Mol Biol 214: 699±710. VanBuren P, Begin K and Warshaw DM (1998) Fluorescent phalloidin enables visualization of actin without eects on myosin's actin ®lament sliding velocity and hydrolytic properties. J Mol Cell Cardiol 30: 2777±2783. Woodrum DT, Rich SA and Pollard TD (1975) Evidence for biased directional polymerization of actin ®lament using heavy meromyosin prepared by an improved method. J Cell Biol 67: 231±237. Wieland T, Devries JX, Schafer A and Faulstich H (1975) Spectroscopic evidence for the interaction of phalloidin with actin. FEBS Lett 54: 73±75. Yasuda R, Miyata H and Kinoshita K Jr (1996) Direct measurement of the torsional rigidity of single actin ®laments. J Mol Biol 263: 227±236.